My Tomato Pie

One of Buffalo's most unique pizza restaurants. Along with our large bar, we offer a private banquet room and full serve catering. The menu includes homemade soups, salad dressings, delicious gourmet pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches served on homemade focaccia bread. Our restaurant is child-friendly and welcomes large parties.

Located at 3055 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228, My Tomato Pie operates as a pizza restaurant serving Amherst in New York. This page gathers the practical details people usually look for before visiting: where it is, how to reach it, when it opens and how customers rate it. Google also lists it under american restaurant, banquet hall, italian restaurant, which is worth knowing if you are comparing several options in the area.

In Amherst, the busiest hours are Friday and Saturday evenings and any night with a big game, when quoted delivery times can stretch past an hour; ordering before 5 p.m. or picking up yourself avoids the wait. Delivery radiuses are small, often two to five miles, and a minimum order plus a delivery fee is normal, with a tip of a few dollars for the driver on top. Lunch specials such as two slices and a drink, or a personal pie, are the cheapest way to eat at most shops across New York on weekdays. Toppings are priced per item and half-and-half pies are usually free to request. Gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese are increasingly common but often cost a few dollars extra, and cross-contact in a shared oven is standard unless the shop says otherwise.

Hours are published for 7 days a week. The most common schedule is 11 am–8 pm. Hours in the United States do change around federal holidays and long weekends, so a quick call before a special trip is sensible. You can reach My Tomato Pie at (716) 838-0969; calling is usually the quickest way to ask about availability, prices or directions. Its website is mytomatopie.com, where you may find menus, price lists or booking options.

On Google it holds a rating of 4.4 out of 5 from 900 reviews, which is a strong result for a pizza restaurant in Amherst and suggests consistent service.

Amherst is in New York, in the Northeast, where four distinct seasons shape local life: hot humid summers, snowy winters that can close businesses for a day, and a dense pattern of towns where walking, transit and street parking all matter. Getting around Amherst is easiest by car; street parking is metered in busy downtown areas, and most suburban businesses have their own lot. Ride-share apps such as Uber and Lyft operate across New York's larger cities, and public transit varies from extensive to minimal.

Looking for alternatives? Browse all pizza restaurants in Amherst or explore other categories in the area from the links below. If you own or manage My Tomato Pie, you can claim this listing to correct details, add photos and a description, and receive a verified badge. Everyone else can help by leaving an honest review on Google after a visit.